This is historical material “frozen in time”. The website is no longer updated and links to external websites and some internal pages may not work.
We the people ask the federal government to Take or explain a position on an issue or policy:

Create a Paid-Off Primary Residence Tax Credit & Allow Paying Off One's Mortgage to be a Tax-Deferred 401k Contribution

Created by S.M. on October 30, 2016

Currently, stock investments in a 401(k) plan will financially outperform paying off one’s mortgage by 70%+ over five years.

Reasons:
*Mortgage interest is tax deductible.
*Mortgages currently available below 4% interest.
*Stock market historically returns 7%.
*Tax-deferred 401(k) retirement savings don’t allow for paying off one’s residence.

This promotes greater debt and larger mortgages.

Result: more risk and more vulnerability to 2008-type systemic shocks.

Proposed:
*A $5000 annual tax credit for “paid-off primary residence” – for anyone who owns their home without a mortgage. This credit would function progressively, encourage borrowing less, and encourage paying one’s mortgage off.
*Allow repaying the principle on one’s mortgage to be a tax-deferred 401k retirement contribution.

Budget & Taxes
Economy & Jobs
Transportation & Infrastructure
Return to top