This is historical material “frozen in time”. The website is no longer updated and links to external websites and some internal pages may not work.

Repeal of the 17th amendment

Created by B.J. on April 18, 2013

because of the passage of the Seventeenth Amendment ,altering the way senators are elected, the states lost any representation they had in the federal government and that, in addition to violating the unamendable state suffrage clause of Article V, this led to the gradual "slide into ignominy" of state legislatures, as well as an overextension of federal power and the rise of special interest groups to fill the power vacuum previously occupied by state legislatures.[2] In addition, concerns have been raised about the power of governors to appoint temporary replacements to fill vacant senate seats, both in terms of how this provision should be interpreted and whether it should be permitted at all. Accordingly, noted public figures have expressed a desire to reform or even repeal.

Government & Regulatory Reform
Return to top