Conduct this experiment:
Every high school student in America would be required to read and discuss any one volume of creationist literature (to be determined) as well as being required to read and discuss one volume of evolutionist literature (my suggestion being The Blind Watchmaker by Richard Dawkins).
Make the experiment part of a required class on critical thinking and debate. Granted a challenge would be to have teachers in all schools who have the training in these disciplines and the willingness and ability to guide the discussion equally from both sides.